By name: hypothesis-formation-quality-gate-check description: 'Shared SOP: General quality-gate check (format completeness, logical consistency)' version: 1.0.0 category: hypothesis-formation type: sop shared: true campaigns:
- gap-prioritization
- hypothesis-formulation
- research-question
input: Any deliverable (gap list / hypothesis / RQ)
output: Pass/fail + issue list
dependencies:
skills:
- subagent-spawning
Quality Gate Check
General quality-gate check — verify the format completeness and logical consistency of a deliverable.
HARD-GATE
Pipeline
- Precondition check: Is the deliverable non-empty
- Format completeness: Does it contain all required fields
- Logical consistency: Are the parts contradictory
- Citation completeness: Do the cited sources exist
- Actionability: Is the deliverable specific and executable enough
- Overall determination: PASS / FAIL
- Output: Determination + issue list (if any)
Check Dimensions
| Dimension | What is checked | FAIL condition |
|---|---|---|
| Format completeness | Are all required fields present | Missing required fields |
| Logical consistency | Are the parts contradictory | Internal contradiction exists |
| Citation completeness | Are cited sources traceable | Citation cannot be verified |
| Actionability | Is it specific enough | Too abstract to execute |
| Unambiguity | Are there multiple interpretations | Key terms are ambiguous |
Output Format
Judgment: PASS / FAIL
Issues found: [count]
Issue list:
1. [dimension]: [specific issue] — [correction suggestion]
2. ...
Severity: CRITICAL / MINOR (per issue)