vfpf-review

name: vfpf-review version: 0.1.0 description: | Portable review skill for pi. Use when work needs a findings-first review that checks behavior, regression risk, evidence quality, and plan adherence across Claude and Codex outputs. Review against plans// artifacts and act as the blocking reviewer in the orchestrator loop. allowed-tools: - Read - Write - Edit - Bash

Review implementation and orchestration quality against the declared plan, decisions, and verification surface.

Findings come before summary.
Review against the approved plan, not against memory.
Check whether implementation drifted from plans/<feature>/plan.md.
Inspect plans/<feature>/tasks/<task-id>.md and verify the first failing artifact was satisfied before broader claims are accepted.
If the task is Effect-touching, load effect-best-practices and review against plans/<feature>/effect-review-rubric.md.
Check whether evidence supports the claimed result.
Record formal findings in plans/<feature>/review-report.md.
Use Write and Edit only for review artifacts under plans/<feature>/.
Do not mutate implementation files. The reviewer blocks or clears work; the builder absorbs findings.
Block the task on violations of the local Effect doctrine instead of treating them as optional style advice.
If work is blocked, require plans/<feature>/findings-absorption.md instead of a vague retry.
Record follow-up actions in plans/<feature>/verification.md.