prep-hb-item

star 0

Create a homebrewed D&D 5e item for the Shattered Sea campaign. Triggers: "homebrew an item for [PC]", "design a [item concept]", "make a custom [item]". Do NOT use for standard 5e items that already exist in RAW — check wiki/entities/items/ first. Full trigger list in the skill body.

Thedougler By Thedougler schedule Updated 6/9/2026

name: prep-hb-item description: > Create a homebrewed D&D 5e item for the Shattered Sea campaign. Triggers: "homebrew an item for [PC]", "design a [item concept]", "make a custom [item]". Do NOT use for standard 5e items that already exist in RAW — check wiki/entities/items/ first. Full trigger list in the skill body.

Shared prep conventions — stub check, interview + PC-connection requirement, combat calibration, prose pass, and filing — live in prep-family-standards. Read it before generating; this file covers only what's specific to this content type.

When to use

Full trigger set: "homebrew an item for [PC]", "design a [item concept]", "make a custom [item]", "I want an item that does [effect]", "create a magic item for [PC]", "invent an item for the setting". Symptoms requiring this skill: desired item doesn't exist in RAW, needs setting-specific mechanics or flavor, or the DM wants to tie an item to a specific PC's story thread.

Prerequisites

Check wiki/index.md for existing item stubs before creating. A reskinned RAW item beats homebrew when the mechanical effect is the same. Only build new if the setting flavor or mechanical concept genuinely can't be satisfied by a RAW item.


Interview

If not answered in the request, ask all at once — not one at a time:

  • Which PC is this for? What tension in their backstory, goals, or fears does this item pull on?
  • What is the one thing this item does — the core mechanic, in one sentence?
  • What rarity target? (Common / Uncommon / Rare / Very Rare / Legendary)
  • What is the narrative reason the party could encounter this item in the current arc?

Name the connecting PC or ask before generating. If you cannot state the one-thing in one sentence, the design is not ready — ask the DM to narrow it.


Power Budget

Set rarity before designing mechanics. Never work backwards from mechanics to rarity.

Read references/RARITY-BUDGET.md for full tier tables and RAW benchmarks.

Quick calibration:

Rarity Power level Attunement
Common Always-on cosmetic or trivial QoL Never
Uncommon One situational advantage — skill or minor combat If combat-relevant
Rare One strong broadly-useful advantage, or two situational Always if combat-altering
Very Rare Game-changing; reshapes encounter design Always
Legendary Campaign-altering Always

Attunement rule: Any item that grants a bonus to attack rolls, damage rolls, saving throws, or AC requires attunement. Three or more distinct powers require attunement regardless of individual power level.

Balance citation: Before writing mechanics, name 2 RAW items at the same rarity and confirm the item's power is comparable. If it's clearly stronger, raise the rarity.


Prohibited Design Space

Never give items these class-exclusive mechanics:

  • Sneak Attack dice (Rogue)
  • Rage or Reckless Attack (Barbarian)
  • Ki points, Stunning Strike, or Step of the Wind (Monk)
  • Bardic Inspiration dice (Bard)
  • Divine Smite (Paladin)
  • Extra Attack beyond what the PC's class already grants

Use item-native design instead: charges that recover on rest, stored spell effects (X charges, cast Y at Zth level), skill/ability check bonuses, AC adjustments, condition immunities, damage resistances.


One-Thing Discipline

Homebrew items do one thing excellently, not three things adequately.

Signs you are designing three things:

  • The Properties section has three H3 headers
  • The item has a combat trigger AND a social trigger AND a passive benefit
  • You reached for "and also..." to make it feel interesting

If the item needs three things, identify which one is the item. The others are future items, or not items at all.


Cross-Skill Coordination

  • NPC vendor: If the item is sold by a named NPC, run prep-npc for that NPC first (or confirm the NPC page exists), then wikilink the item to their page and add a reciprocal link on the NPC's Connections section.
  • Location context: If the item is tied to a specific location (dungeon treasure, shop inventory, wreck salvage), ensure that location page exists and add a reciprocal wikilink.
  • Called from prep-dungeon: If this skill is invoked mid-dungeon to fill a treasure slot, deliver the complete item wiki page, then return to prep-dungeon and place the item reference in the relevant room's Features block using italic typographic encoding. The DM review gate still applies — present the item before the dungeon Phase 4 output.
  • Session prep: If prep-session is requesting an item as a session prop or reward, complete the DM review gate before the session plan is finalized. An unapproved homebrew item in a session plan is a forward commitment to balance.

Output Structure

Flavor description — two to four sentences. Appearance, provenance, feel in hand. No mechanical content. Read-aloud quality: a player could read this before picking it up.

Stat line — one line immediately after: *[Type] · [Rarity] · [Attunement or No attunement]*

## Properties

  • Label every homebrew mechanic with **[HB]**
  • Label any RAW-borrowed mechanics with **[RAW]**
  • Bound every mechanic: range, duration, recovery (long rest / short rest / X charges / at-will)
  • State edge cases: undead, unconscious targets, environments (underwater, darkness, etc.)

## Limitations — What the item cannot do. Explicit limits prevent table arguments.

## History — Provenance in Shattered Sea. Who made it, who owned it, how it arrived here.

> [!dm] — DM secrets, hidden mechanics, future hooks. Nothing in this callout is player-facing.

## Current Location — Where is it now? Who holds, sells, or guards it?

## Connections — Wikilinks to the connected PC(s), NPC(s), locations, factions.


Frontmatter

Standard entity fields auto-complete. Author these item-specific values:

Field What goes here
item_type weapon / armor / wondrous / tool / ammunition
rarity common / uncommon / rare / very-rare / legendary / artifact
attunement true or false
homebrew Always true for this skill
asking_price gp value as string — omit entirely if not for sale

DM Review Gate

Present the item to the DM before committing. State: the one-thing, the rarity justification, and the two RAW benchmarks. Wait for approval before writing to the wiki.

Homebrew items affect game balance at the table. A misbalanced item is harder to retract after players have used it. This gate is not optional.


Visual Aid

For named, PC-relevant items: load ttrpg-visual-aids after DM approval. Category: Props (1:1 square, object-focused). Skip for items never described to players.


Filing

After DM approval:

  1. wiki/entities/items/{slug}.md
  2. Add entry to wiki/index.md under ## entities/items
  3. Add reciprocal links in all connected entity files (PC page, NPC vendor, location)
  4. Commit: feat: item — {slug} — {one-line summary}

Load ttrpg-writing before writing any prose. DM-facing reference for DM callout, history, and limitations. Player-facing prose for flavor description (read-aloud quality — a player could read this before picking up the item).


Reference Files

File Read when
references/RARITY-BUDGET.md Setting rarity and checking power against RAW benchmarks
../ttrpg-writing/references/dm-reference-standards.md Writing DM callout, history, limitations
../ttrpg-writing/references/player-facing-prose.md Writing flavor description
../ttrpg-writing/references/callout-standard.md Callout type enforcement and conversion
../ttrpg-llm-wiki-init/references/auto-correct.md Fixing structural issues
../ttrpg-llm-wiki-init/references/wikilink-standards.md Creating or fixing wikilinks
Install via CLI
npx skills add https://github.com/Thedougler/shattered-sea-wiki --skill prep-hb-item
Repository Details
star Stars 0
call_split Forks 0
navigation Branch main
article Path SKILL.md
More from Creator