By name: skills description: Multi-stage rebuttal analysis skill for RebuttalStudio. Use when organizing reviewer comments into stage-specific conference workflows, including stage1 breakdown, stage2 refinement, stage4 multi-round follow-up, and stage5 final remarks generation.
RebuttalStudio Multi-Stage Skill
Follow this dispatcher structure:
- Identify stage first (
stage1,stage2,stage4, orstage5). - For
stage1andstage2, apply the stage template first, then select conference-specific extension. - Execute the conference skill instructions directly.
Available stage workflows
stage1/template/SKILL.md: Shared Stage 1 breakdown template. Apply before conference overrides.stage1/iclr/SKILL.md: Convert raw reviewer feedback into a structured breakdown for rebuttal drafting.stage1/icml/SKILL.md: Convert raw reviewer feedback into a structured breakdown for rebuttal drafting (ICML mapping).stage2/template/SKILL.md: Shared Stage 2 refine template. Apply before conference overrides.stage2/iclr/SKILL.md: Refine Stage2 outline drafts into reviewer-facing rebuttal prose.stage2/icml/SKILL.md: Refine Stage2 outline drafts into reviewer-facing rebuttal prose (ICML labeling).stage4/condense/SKILL.md: Condense Stage 3 combined discussion into reusable markdown context.stage4/refine/SKILL.md: Refine follow-up response using condensed context + follow-up question + user draft.stage5/final-remarks/SKILL.md: Fill Stage 5 final remarks template from all reviewers' condensed markdown context.
Available utility workflows
polish/SKILL.md: Polish (rephrase) a rebuttal message template for clarity and professionalism while preserving the original structure, tone, and intent.
Available stage-general utility skills
These skills apply across multiple stages and provide strategic, stylistic, and quality guidance:
utility/stage/review-response/SKILL.md: Comment classification (Major/Minor/Misunderstanding/Typo) and response strategy selection (Accept/Defend/Clarify/Experiment). Use when planning how to respond to any reviewer concern.utility/stage/writing-anti-ai/SKILL.md: Remove AI-generated writing patterns from rebuttal prose. Use after Stage 2 refinement or Stage 4 follow-up when text reads formulaic or robotic.utility/stage/text-condense/SKILL.md: Condense selected rebuttal prose into fewer words without changing meaning. Use when a paragraph is too long but the technical content should stay intact.utility/stage/rebuttal-self-review/SKILL.md: Pre-submission quality checklist covering coverage, tone, factual accuracy, structure, and clarity. Use after Stage 3 compilation or Stage 5 final remarks.utility/stage/citation-verification/SKILL.md: Verification workflow for any new citation added during rebuttal writing. Use when LLM-suggested references appear in Stage 2 drafts.
If a requested stage/conference does not exist, stop and ask for missing spec before inventing format. When adding a new conference for Stage 1 or Stage 2, extend the stage template and edit only conference-specific differences.