use-correct-github-review-comment-enums

name: use-correct-github-review-comment-enums description: Enforce schema-correct enum values when posting GitHub PR review comments via MCP tools. Use when creating inline review comments or handling tool validation errors for review-thread parameters.

Goal

Prevent avoidable GitHub MCP tool failures caused by invalid enum values or casing in review-comment payloads.

When to Use

• You call mcp__github__add_comment_to_pending_review.
• You create or submit PR review comments with enum fields such as subjectType or side.
• A prior tool call failed with GraphQL validation mentioning enum mismatch.

Rules

1. Validate enum fields before sending:

• subjectType must be LINE or FILE.
• side and startSide should use LEFT or RIGHT when present.

2. Prefer subjectType: LINE for inline code comments.
3. Include path and line for inline comments; use subjectType: FILE only for file-level comments.
4. If a validation error reports enum mismatch, retry once with corrected enum casing/values without changing comment meaning.
5. Do not repeat retries beyond one automatic correction attempt.
6. Keep review text unchanged while fixing transport/schema fields.

Procedure

1. Build comment payload and preflight-check enum fields.
2. Send tool call.
3. If response contains enum-validation error:

• map invalid enum values to valid constants (LINE/FILE, LEFT/RIGHT),
• resend exactly once.

4. Confirm comment presence by reading review comments after successful submission.

Quick Reference

• Correct: subjectType: "LINE"
• Incorrect: subjectType: "line"