sim-analyze

name: sim-analyze description: Analyze a cache trace file to understand its characteristics and recommend policies argument-hint: "" context: fork disable-model-invocation: true allowed-tools: Read, Grep, Glob, Bash

Analyze the given cache trace to understand its access pattern characteristics and recommend which cache policies would perform best.

Input

Trace file: $ARGUMENTS

Workflow

1. Identify the trace format and read the trace:

   • Check file extension, try to parse first lines
   • Determine: key-only or weighted? Timestamps included?
   • Count total accesses and distinct keys

2. Compute trace statistics. Write a small analysis script or use the simulator's synthetic tools to characterize:

   • Working set size: number of distinct keys
   • Temporal working set: distinct keys in sliding windows
   • Frequency distribution: how many keys account for 80% of accesses? (Zipfian? Uniform? Bimodal?)
   • Recency patterns: what fraction of accesses are repeats within the last N accesses?
   • Scan detection: are there bursts of sequential unique keys?
   • Temporal shifts: does the popular set change over time? (Compare first half vs second half frequency rankings)

3. Characterize the workload:

   • Frequency-biased: few hot keys dominate → LFU/TinyLFU excel
   • Recency-biased: recent items are reaccessed → LRU/LIRS excel
   • Mixed: both signals matter → W-TinyLFU, ARC
   • Scan-heavy: sequential scans pollute → scan-resistant policies (S3-FIFO, 2Q)
   • Shifting: popular set changes over time → adaptive policies (hill climber)

4. Recommend policies for comparison:

   • Match trace characteristics to policy strengths
   • Suggest cache sizes based on working set (10%, 25%, 50% of distinct keys)
   • Predict which policies will likely win and why

5. Run a quick validation. Execute a single-size simulation using simulator:run (not simulator:simulate which does multi-size):

   ./gradlew simulator:run -q \
     -Dcaffeine.simulator.files.paths.0="format:path" \
     -Dcaffeine.simulator.maximum-size=SIZE \
     -Dcaffeine.simulator.policies.0=product.Caffeine \
     -Dcaffeine.simulator.policies.1=opt.Clairvoyant \
     -Dcaffeine.simulator.policies.2=linked.Lru
   

   Note: each policy creates instances per admission filter (default: Always, TinyLfu, Clairvoyant). If a trace has no weight data, weighted-only policies are silently skipped.

6. Report:

   • Trace summary (accesses, distinct keys, frequency distribution shape)
   • Workload characterization (frequency vs recency bias)
   • Recommended policies with reasoning
   • Quick validation results
   • Suggested /sim-compare invocation for full analysis