codex-with-cc-reviewing

name: codex-with-cc-reviewing description: Review codex-with-cc worker reports, verification evidence, changed files, and findings before accepting or returning delegated work.

Codex with CC Reviewing

Read ../codex-with-cc/CODEX_WITH_CC.md before reviewing delegated results.

Review duties:

• Verify the run artifact with verify_delegate_run.* or verify_delegate_artifacts.*.
• Confirm the worker was launched from a TaskFile with the required contract sections, not an inline prompt.
• Confirm generated or risky task files would pass validate_delegate_task.*.
• Check that Status and Final Result use the same valid status token.
• Check that Role matches the delegated role.
• Check that reviewer runs include ReviewForTaskId and ReviewKind.
• Inspect Changed Files and Verification for concrete evidence.
• Reject DONE reports that do not name commands actually run and their outcomes.
• Reject non-dry-run DONE reports that omit commands passed through -Tests.
• Treat DONE_WITH_CONCERNS, NEEDS_CONTEXT, BLOCKED, and FAIL as requiring main-thread judgment before acceptance.
• Return the task for rework when findings are valid and actionable.

Use two passes:

1. Spec compliance review: did the worker do exactly the assigned task, stay inside scope, and meet acceptance criteria?
2. Quality review: are the changes maintainable, minimal, tested, and unlikely to regress adjacent behavior?

Do not accept an implementer task at workflow level until both review passes are accepted in the workflow artifact.